The room he came from

Thirty-one teams in this league hire an evaluator the way you’d hire the plumber your cousin used once. Somebody vouches, somebody says he interviews well. Then one family in Cleveland pulled up seven years of published grades and scored them like a test, and football decided that was the crazy part.

[music]

So. I went back and graded all of it. Not the mocks — the mocks are noise, they have always been noise. The grades. Two hundred and ninety-one videos, seven big boards, 2019 through 2025, nothing unlisted, nothing quietly pulled down, which, I have pulled a video down. I won’t sit here and act like I haven’t.

Full disclosure, this started as a twelve-minute thing. Then I fell down four rabbit holes, one of which was a second-contract table by draft round going back to 2019, which is not a thing a well person does in May. Buckle up.

You cannot grade a board on where guys went. That’s a mock. You can grade whether the player turned into a professional football player, so I used two flags. A second contract from anybody, and two thousand career snaps. Blunt travels across positions. Clever does not.

Three points. Three! If I stopped here you’d be right to say okay, he’s the same as everybody, why does he have two chairs. Wrong table, and it’s the one everybody builds first.

Twenty and eight when he’s fading somebody. I ran it three times because I didn’t trust it, then I watched what he was fading, because a number without a mechanism is a horoscope. He fades length and testing on a man who plays with his eyes closed. He buys the player who solves it a half-second early.

Other half of the ledger, because this channel does not do one-sided videos. The interview was for a personnel role. That is on the record. And the release cost a hundred and seventeen point six against this year’s cap, which everybody keeps calling a record. It is a record for one player, not for a team. Miami’s is worse. The acceleration is a January decision, not a Watson decision. Take it in March and you eat it in two pieces. Somebody chose one piece.

Which brings me to April. The consensus number on Iheanachor was twenty-third. I had him twenty-first. Cleveland took him ninth. What I want to argue is not whether that’s a reach. It is a reach against the number and the number is right there. What I want to argue is whether the number deserves the authority we hand it.

Because a consensus board is thirty people watching the same four games and grading each other’s grades. If your process is built to find the man nobody else has, agreeing with consensus is evidence it stopped working, and disagreeing is not evidence it is working. That is the [ __ ] of building on your own board.

Then he does it again on the next card, and that is the one I had to build a spreadsheet for. Here is where the field had all three of them going into that night.

Cleveland was sitting at twenty-four. They sent twenty-four, a fourth this year and their second next year to get to ten. Old chart, ten is thirteen hundred, twenty-four is seven forty, the fourth is sixty of it, and the second next year is the rest of it and then some. That is a market price. Nobody robbed anybody. What you paid market for is a jump of fourteen spots to take the twenty-second player on the board, with the receiver everybody had eight spots ahead of him sitting right there, who then went ten picks later.

So if what you want to say is he reached twice, you are reading the board correctly and I am not going to talk you out of it. I want to be precise about the second one, because reached and reached and paid a second are two different sentences and only one of them shows up on next year’s spreadsheet.

And here is the part that will irritate everybody who wanted me on one side of this. Go back up to that second table. Nineteen and fourteen when he is higher than the field. Fifty-eight percent. That is a coin flip in a nice jacket. Twenty and eight is the fade, and the fade is where his edge lives, and a trade up is the opposite of a fade. He spent real capital in the one direction the record does not say he is special in. I ran that twice too.

So I’ve really come to believe in three things.

Number one. He isn’t lucky. Sixty-one disagreements is a real sample, twenty and eight on the fades is not a thing you fall into, and the evaluation underneath this holds up when you check it. I checked it.

Number two. The reason he got the job is not that he was good. There are plenty of good evaluators and most of them are broke. He was good and checkable, and only one of those is visible from outside a building.

Number three, and this is the one I would go to the wall for. This is not a predictive mock. I don’t think anybody can predict where guys are going to go. I do think the evaluations and the grades that I have on these players are something we can look back on in three, four, five years and see if I was right about the players. That’s all I care about. Somebody just got paid on that standard.

So no, I don’t know whether Cleveland is going to be any good. I know the tackle gets graded in public every Sunday for four years, and so does the man who took him, and thirty-one teams will go on hiring the plumber their cousin used once.

[music] [music] [music]

Description. Spreadsheet linked. Factor · code FILMROOMFB50. Bootleg Football twice weekly with E.J. Snyder. #nflpartner